Storytelling has always shaped how humans learn and connect. In simulation-based experiences it plays a crucial role too. By weaving personal, clinical, and educational narratives into structured debriefings, facilitators can engage learners, normalize challenges, and highlight key lessons. Adam Cheng and Vincent Grant explore the art of storytelling within debriefing, illustrating how it can be used in a strategic and thoughtful manner to maximize impact and enhance the overall learning experience.
In today’s fast-paced world, where information is abundant and attention is fleeting, storytelling emerges as a timeless method to engage, educate, and inspire learners. The art of storytelling isn’t just reserved for authors or filmmakers. It holds valuable lessons for professionals across fields, especially in areas like debriefing, where the power of narrative can transform routine feedback conversations into impactful and unforgettable learning experiences. Storytelling isn’t just about recounting events, but rather about weaving emotions and key lessons into a narrative that resonates with your learner group. In this article, we explore the art of storytelling within debriefing, illustrating how it can be used in a strategic and thoughtful manner to maximize impact and enhance the overall learning experience.
Why do Stories Matter?
Stories have been around for centuries because they are one of the most effective ways to communicate knowledge, build culture, and evoke emotion1. Stories apply structure to our lived experiences, and provide a means for us to make sense of the world around us. They have the unique ability to illustrate the significance of key points by connecting with audiences on an emotional level. Stories consolidate knowledge, create memories and forge connections among individuals and teams, thus helping to maximize the impact of learning conversations1. Storytelling can elevate conversations, facilitate learning, and foster community.
By leveraging personal, clinical, and educational stories, we can create a richer and more engaging learning environment within debriefing conversations.
What Types of Stories can be used in Debriefing?
While we all carry with us a collection of stories from our prior experiences, there are several specific categories of stories that can be used in an intentional manner to enrich healthcare simulation debriefings. We encourage educators to reflect on their prior experiences and think about how they can be woven into your debriefings to give them depth and relevance. To effectively integrate storytelling into debriefing, consider these three key categories of stories:
- Personal Stories
Sharing anecdotes from personal experiences can illuminate important lessons learned from real-life examples. These stories can help to personalize abstract concepts and forge a connection between the facilitator and learners.
- Clinical Stories
Relating experiences from the front lines of clinical care, involving patients, families, and healthcare teams, can be a powerful way to amplify key take home messages. These stories can bring to life the complexities and challenges of real-world situations, highlighting patient interactions and teamwork in healthcare settings.
- Educational Stories
Using narratives from teaching interactions, simulation sessions or debriefings can convey lessons learned and stimulate reflection on how we can improve future learning.
The Role of Stories in the Debriefing Framework
Stories have a unique adaptability, fitting seamlessly into various stages of debriefing frameworks, such as the PEARLS (Promoting Excellence and Reflective Learning in Simulation) blended-method debriefing framework2. Stories can be strategically used to across all phases of the debriefing process. During the reactions phase, stories can be used to engage participants or address emotional responses. As analysis begins, stories can serve any purpose: to engage learners, normalize behaviors (or outcomes), emphasize key points, or resolve differences. Finally, in the summary phase, stories help tie up loose ends, resolve lingering issues, and reinforce key takeaways.
Here are four primary ways stories can be used to enhance debriefings:
1. Engage: use stories to capture attention. Narrate an “experience I’ll never forget” or a “moment when everything changed” to draw listeners in, making them eager to learn more. For example, during the analysis phase, a story of how an unforgettable vacation experiencing a new culture can be used to highlight the importance of inclusivity and acceptance when communication with patients and families from other cultures.
2. Emphasize: stories can reinforce key learning points by sharing an “unbelievable win” or similar narrative at crucial moments in the debriefing. For example, a story describing how amazing teamwork resulted in an incredible outcome in a critically ill patient can be used to highlight the importance of teamwork.
3. Normalize: facilitators may choose to demonstrate vulnerability by sharing stories of failure or setbacks, which can help to create psychological safety by flattening hierarchy3. This can help participants see that they are not alone, building confidence and making them feel more comfortable to discuss their own challenges. For example, in a debriefing where learners are upset having missed a critical finding, the debriefer may choose to tell a story of a similar oversight or error, thus demonstrating to learners that they can understand and appreciate how the learners must feel.
4. Resolve: stories may be used to bridge differences and address conflict amongst learners. For example, a “lessons learned” story with a similar or related context can guide participants toward mutual understanding and agreement.
Constructing and Delivering a Compelling Story
The purpose of stories in debriefing are to generate interest and curiosity, share information in an accessible manner, and also forge a stronger facilitator-learner connection. Well-crafted stories make the content personally relevant and allow learners to immerse themselves within the narrative and world of the story4. While many approaches to telling stories have been described, most contain several key common elements to consider:
1. Setting the Scene: introduce where and when the story takes place, the characters involved, and the initial situation or problem. This “exposition” is crucial.
2. Conflict and Climax: introduce a challenge or problem (rising action) that leads to the climax, where characters confront the main issue.
3. Resolution and Reflection: describe how the problem is resolved, drawing out consequences, and, most importantly, lessons learned. These reflections should be relevant and applicable to the audience’s context.
4. Emotional Engagement: ensure there’s something at stake for the characters, which relates to why listeners should care.
A frequently missed opportunity in storytelling is setting the scene adequately. Engaging your audience by vividly describing the environment and characters, their thoughts, and emotions at key moments will promote learner immersion within your story. The delivery of your story can be as crucial as its content. Facilitators should work to ensure their tone, pace, and body language matches the story’s emotional beats.
Conclusions
Integrating stories into debriefings is more than just adding a narrative element; it’s about creating a shared experience that fosters deeper understanding and connection. Stories engage, normalize, emphasize, and resolve, making them an indispensable tool in any professional’s toolkit. By weaving them thoughtfully into debriefing sessions, we not only enhance communication but also build a culture of learning and growth. Engage your audience not just with facts, but with stories they’ll remember and learn from!
Acknowledgement
This article contains original content from a ‘Concept Overview’ lesson in the Advanced Debriefing course of the Academy Archive (www.academyarchive.com) featuring Adam Cheng. Descript (generative AI software) was used to summarize the main messages from the lesson, which was then edited by both Adam Cheng and Vincent Grant for grammar, punctuation, readability, and accuracy.
Declaration Of The Usage Of Ai
Descript (generative AI software) was used to summarize the main messages from the lesson, which was then edited by both Adam Cheng and Vincent Grant for grammar, punctuation, readability, and accuracy.
References
1. Landrum RE, Brakke K. The pedagogical power of storytelling. Scholarship of Teaching and Learning in Psychology. 2019;5(3):247-53.
2. Eppich W, Cheng A. Promoting Excellence and Reflective Learning in Simulation (PEARLS): development and rationale for a blended approach to health care simulation debriefing. Simul Healthc. 2015;10(2):106-15.
3. Molloy E, Bearman M. Embracing the tension between vulnerability and credibility: ‘intellectual candour’ in health professions education. Med Educ. 2019;53(1):32-41.4. Green MC, Brock TC. The role of transportation in the persuasiveness of public narratives. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. 2000;79:701-21.
READ ALSO
